Is your university’s digital workplace a model of success? For many, the answer is a reluctant no.
In this blog, we’ll explore eight symptoms of a fractured digital workplace in Higher Education, what an effective environment should look like, and how senior IT leaders can take the reins to deliver the connected, secure, and user-focused experience staff and students now expect.
A Challenging Reality
Digital workplace initiatives have been on the agenda in Higher Education for years. Most universities have invested heavily—often in Microsoft 365—and yet, the reality frequently falls short. Tools are there, but the experience remains fragmented.
At its best, the digital workplace enables academic and professional services staff to access tools, data, and communications from anywhere—supporting teaching, research, and administration. But simply having the tools in place isn’t enough. What’s needed is a cohesive environment where collaboration, productivity, knowledge sharing, and student engagement come together in one seamless digital ecosystem.
In too many universities, that vision is still unrealised. Despite the promise of Microsoft 365, we still see scattered tools, inconsistent user journeys, and disengaged staff. The problem isn’t with the tech—it’s how it’s being adopted and architected.
How can you tell if your institution’s digital workplace isn’t delivering? Here are the tell-tale signs.
Eight Symptoms of a Broken Digital Workplace in Higher Education
“Broken” may sound dramatic, but what we’re really talking about is underperformance. These eight symptoms are common across universities that are struggling to create a joined-up digital experience:
1. Disjointed Experience
There’s no single hub for academic and administrative tasks. Lecturers, researchers, and professional services staff have to navigate multiple portals, apps, and logins just to do their jobs—costing time and causing frustration.
2. Time Wasted Searching for Content
Without a centralised, easily searchable repository, staff waste time hunting for the right policy, the latest version of a module guide, or shared research data. The absence of a unified “source of truth” is a common frustration.
3. Siloed Knowledge Across Faculties & Departments
Departmental autonomy can be a strength—but when it comes to data and systems, it often results in isolated information, duplicated documents, and patchy version control. Collaboration across faculties and central services suffers as a result.
4. Overdependence on Email & Meetings
If email is still your default for project updates, committee collaboration, or student communication, your digital workplace isn’t working as it should. Heavy reliance on meetings and inboxes often indicates underused tools like Teams and poor visibility of cross-departmental activity.
5. Legacy Systems Holding You Back
Many universities still depend on legacy or custom-built platforms for back-office systems. These systems are often inflexible, on-premises, and difficult to integrate—making true digital transformation difficult to scale.
6. Staff Frustration & Low Adoption
When systems are hard to use, staff revert to their own methods—resulting in shadow IT, poor uptake of institutional tools, and digital disengagement. The symptoms show up in surveys, adoption dashboards, and rising support tickets.
7. Patchy Security & Compliance
Inconsistent access controls, sensitive data shared informally, and a lack of visibility over third-party integrations all point to an environment that’s out of step with modern security expectations. Regulatory compliance—especially with FOI, GDPR, and research ethics—is at risk.
8. No Clear Strategy or Digital Ownership
Is your digital workplace led by IT? Or by individual departments? Without a unified vision, decisions are made in isolation and investments duplicated. Staff and students are left to navigate a confusing, often inconsistent, landscape of systems and services.
Know What's Working & What's Not
Why Universities Struggle to Deliver a Connected Digital Experience
University IT teams face unique challenges. Many operate in decentralised environments, where faculties and research centres have a strong influence over their own digital tools. This autonomy can make it hard to enforce a consistent digital strategy across the institution.
Add to that the difficulty of replacing legacy systems built years (or decades) ago, often with no APIs, and the political sensitivity of changing long-standing platforms tied to academic processes—and it’s easy to see why progress stalls.
On top of this, IT teams are overstretched. Budgets are tight. Expectations are high. And the focus is often on keeping systems running rather than shaping how work should happen. Too often, short-term firefighting takes priority over long-term transformation.
The result? A patchwork of disconnected tools, unclear governance, and a user experience that’s functional at best—and frustrating at worst.
What a High-Functioning Digital Workplace Looks Like for Universities
The building blocks are already in place. Microsoft 365, used well, has everything needed to create a secure, intuitive, and connected digital workplace tailored to the Higher Education context.
Here’s what success looks like:
One Entry Point for All Work
A central SharePoint intranet or digital staff hub, providing unified access to tools, policies, forms, and systems—from research finance to student services.
Consistent, Intuitive Navigation
Branded, role-based portals that make it easy for lecturers, researchers, and admin teams to find what they need, with integrations with third-party platforms like Moodle, HR systems, or library tools.
Smart Information Architecture
Structured SharePoint libraries with metadata, permissions, and automated governance using Microsoft Syntex. No more guesswork or duplicated versions.
Streamlined Collaboration
Microsoft Teams becomes the true hub for real-time collaboration—used across committees, course design teams, and research groups—while Viva Engage supports community building and internal comms.
Platform-Agnostic Experience
Whether on campus or remote, on desktop or mobile, staff can access the same intuitive experience. Documents live in the cloud, co-authoring is easy, and everything’s backed up and secure.
Productivity Tools with Real Impact
Power Automate reduces administrative load by automating common processes (think expense approvals or student placement tracking). Power Apps enables low-code app creation for departmental needs. Power BI brings institutional data to life for decision-makers.
People-First Design with Microsoft Viva
Viva Insights supports wellbeing. Viva Learning integrates CPD. Viva Connections brings news and resources into a familiar flow. It’s a digital space that supports more than just tasks—it supports people.
Enterprise-Grade Security Built-In
From conditional access and MFA through Entra ID, to sensitivity labels and guest access control, Microsoft 365 bakes in compliance and governance, without compromising ease of use.
IT’s Role in Enabling University-Wide Transformation
University IT teams are in a unique position to shape the digital campus experience. While business-owned, the digital workplace must be IT-led—with strong governance, a unified strategy, and a relentless focus on usability.
This means building cross-departmental coalitions with HR, research, comms, and academic leadership. But it also means IT must lead on user experience—not just leave it to others. Design, adoption, training, and change management all flow from a people-first digital strategy.
What to Do Next: Strategy, Review, and Roadmap
If you recognise the symptoms, the first step is review. What tools are live? Which are underused? Where are the silos? What are staff actually using day to day?
Start with small wins that build momentum. Consolidate where possible—make SharePoint your foundation. Consider a real single-entry-point staff or faculty portal. Reimagine how documents are stored, shared, and surfaced.
Don’t try to do everything at once. Break the work into achievable phases. Bring in trusted partners to support and guide you, especially when it comes to shaping the business case, prioritising workstreams, and securing leadership buy-in.
You’re Closer Than You Think
It’s easy to feel overwhelmed. But the truth is, most universities already have the tools—they just need the strategy, skills, and support to bring them together.
Digital transformation in Higher Education doesn’t have to start from scratch. With Microsoft 365, the foundation is already there. It’s about making better use of what you have, and aligning it to the people and processes that make your institution work.
The connected, secure, and empowering digital workplace your university needs? It’s not a distant ambition. It’s entirely achievable—and IT can lead the way.
Optimise SharePoint for Your Institution
See how universities are auditing and evolving their SharePoint to better support staff and students.
Explore What’s Possible with Microsoft 365
See how Higher Education leaders are transforming collaboration and connection across campus.
